Should I kill or save Jimmy Brooks?

Arthur then has the choice of either saving Jimmy or letting him die: If Arthur chooses to kill him: Not wishing to take any chances with him, Arthur ensures that Jimmy won’t say a word by stamping on his hands and thus causing him to plummet to his death. For this, the player will lose Honor.

Should I sell the pen from Jimmy Brooks?

You can sell it for a decent price at the fence if you wish. Yes. One of the members of the gang tells you that they wish they had such a pen. If you sold it there is another one in a small house in the east.

What happens if you kill Anthony Foreman?

If the player chooses to kill Foreman: Arthur says that he doesn’t want to take any chances and proceeds to impale Foreman in the torso with a knife, killing him. If the player chooses to spare Foreman: Arthur unties Foreman’s hands and tells him to go; the two men never encounter each other again.

Did Dutch have a brain injury?

RDR2: Dutch suffered a severe brain injury in chapter 4 that contributed to his radical change in behaviour.

How do I give the pen to Mary Beth?

Just head East from Emerald Ranch, and you’ll see these names appear on the map. Inside the house, there’s a dead old lady. Examine the drawers in the house and you’ll find the fountain pen. Head back to Mary Beth and you’ll now be able to give it to her.

How do you trigger Mary Beth fountain pen?

Fountain Pen in RDR2 is an item you need for the Mary-Beth request mission. You can take this request mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 from Mary-Beth in Chapter 2. She will ask you to get her the fountain pen.

How do I trigger a Dutch pipe request?

Sometimes you need to do missions to trigger “ask/fetch” quests & other time a (few) spawn reload(s) in camp will do the trick. Pearson also has a request while playing poker with him. If you know what the items are & where to find them you can get the items before they even make the requests.

Where is Mary Beth a pen?

Mary-Beth — Fountain Pen location You’ll find the Fountain Pen for Mary-Beth in the cabin named Osman Grove, located just a little east-southeast of Emerald Station and Emerald Ranch. The Fountain Pen is in the drawer of the table next to the dead old woman in a rocking chair.

Where is Dutch’s pipe?

The Pipe is located in a hut east of Pronghorn Ranch, in the West Elizabeth region. Inside the hut is a bear but you can throw some dynamite inside to take it down instantly. Dutch can give this errand to you at your gang’s hideout in Chapter 2, Chapter 3, or Chapter 4 between 8:00 – 20:00 at day.

How do you give a Molly pocket mirror?

Inside the hut you can find the pocket mirror on a nightstand by a bed. In order to deliver it you need to get Molly’s errand request first. She gives it to you at your gang’s hideout in Chapter 3 between 8:00 – 20:00 at day. Fulfilling 5 errands is a requirement for the Errand Boy trophy and achievement.

How do you trigger camps in rdr2?

Players initiate this item request by picking up a book titled “The Tale of The Deceitful German” near Hosea – it’s found in camp. Arthur can then search for another book to give to his old friend.

How do you trigger an item request on Molly?

When Mary Beth is sitting writing in her journal you can have a conversation about a big desk and a pen it generates the request. You have to talk to Molly when she is doing her make up. Dutch will be smoking a cigar outside his tent to generate the pipe request.

Where is the Tilly necklace in RDR2?

You can find the Jack Hall Treasure early on in Red Dead Redemption 2. It contains a pearl necklace that you can either sell for $4 or give to Tilly. The map above highlights its location. You’ll find it in the Hanging Dog Ranch, just to the north of the Little Creek River.

Where is Jack’s book in RDR2?

The Penny Dreadful titled “Wild West Heroes No. 132” can be found at the Downes Ranch which is directly west of Caliban’s Seat and is south-west of Valentine (it’s highlighted with the red patch on the map above). The comic can be located in the farmhouse, in the bedroom, in the nightstand which is next to the bed.

What does Sadie give you for the harmonica?

Harmonica gift for Sadie. On the way back to the camp you will find out that Sadie would very much like to have a harmonica. After completing the mission, you can find Sadie in the camp and give her a harmonica – hold down the left trigger and press the donation button.

What does Dutch give you for the pipe?

There’s a desk with a typewriter in the shack – that’s where you’ll find the pipe. Simply grab it and bring it to Dutch next time you’re in your camp, and you’ll get a pair of new spurs as a reward.

Can you give candy to Jack?

Give Candy To Jack To Get His Costume Items You can give Jack a piece of Candy twice to receive the Jack’s Robe and Jack’s Face costume clothing items shown below. After that, he will only give sets of Pumpkins, so we don’t recommend bothering with a third piece of Candy and beyond.

What do you get for finding all the dinosaur bones in RDR2?

After speaking with her, she’ll give you a mission called, “A Test of Faith.” She asks you to travel around to discover 30 dinosaur bones hidden across the map. In addition to working toward the completion of a quest and its rewards, each bone found gives you +5 Dead Eye XP, which will help you upgrade that skill.

What happens when you find all the rock carvings RDR2?

Collecting the RDR2 Rock Carvings will provide you with the following rewards. Once you have completed all ten of the Rock Carvings and read Francis Sinclair’s Invitation Letter, you can visit him at his cabin to receive an Old Brass Compass. You can find the complete list of all ten Rock Carvings below.

Can I get into Fort Wallace RDR2?

If you are not on max health to run and hogtie the soldiers your honor might be decreased significantly. Soldiers will respawn inside the fort every few minutes so keep that in mind. Yes you can.

Is there anything in Fort Mercer RDR2?

In Free Roam, Fort Mercer is a gang hideout occupied by the Bollard Twins Gang. The LeMat Revolver is located here, in a crate on the roof of one of the rear buildings. There is also a Gatling Gun on the roof of the fort. The player must kill all of the bandits in the fort, as well as the Bollard Twins gang boss.